tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3442555339667770589.post884749148991415702..comments2024-03-18T22:56:06.696+05:30Comments on Jayasree Saranathan: 6. Pāzhi- Pāli- Māgadhā - Shāka Dweepa connection known from Tamil texts.Jayasree Saranathan http://www.blogger.com/profile/01048252011566427834noreply@blogger.comBlogger10125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3442555339667770589.post-56739132066608757292018-04-24T21:39:05.718+05:302018-04-24T21:39:05.718+05:30@ Josh / Joe,
I went through the old comments to...@ Josh / Joe, <br /><br />I went through the old comments to see from where you are coming. You originally wrote a comment on July 2017 in Valmiki article on Manushya Bhasha. (http://jayasreesaranathan.blogspot.in/2013/03/valmiki-of-ramayana-knew-tamil-spoken.html)<br /><br />That is the first article of a series on deducing the manushya bhasha mentioned in Ramayana. So far 8 articles have been posted and a few more to continue wherein the main idea is to establish that Tamil co-existed with Sanskrit. A secondary idea is the existence of a proto language from which both evolved. The detailed analysis is yet to be written there. Once done it will be published in a concise form both in Tamil and English. With the available inputs I have gathered, it stands out that Pali serves as a candidate for proto language of ancient India from which Tamil and Sanskrit were improvised separately. The current article (above) gives a conjectural connection between Pali and old Tamil / Tamil land / culture. <br /><br />Jayasree Saranathan https://www.blogger.com/profile/01048252011566427834noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3442555339667770589.post-33871533298778046342018-04-24T15:07:29.122+05:302018-04-24T15:07:29.122+05:30Words, and no concrete stuff. Words, and no concrete stuff. Jayasree Saranathan https://www.blogger.com/profile/01048252011566427834noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3442555339667770589.post-88421009416572752742018-04-24T14:30:30.569+05:302018-04-24T14:30:30.569+05:30'Your comment is superfluous. Be specific wher...'Your comment is superfluous. Be specific where you differ and tell why you differ / or don't agree. <br />There is a proto language to both Tamil and Sanskrit as both have been refined and developed simultaneously according to Tamil texts. This article gives conjectural evidence to what that could be. There are solid evidences to show that Pali fits with the bill. They are yet to be written in this series.'<br /><br />Superfluous? If it is not, most people do not understand where I am coming from. I hope you would ignore the redundancies if any. I wrote this to make clear. <br /><br />I am neutral on this and I am not going to be personally involved or emotional at this. I neither agree not disagree until or unless it has been proven. I know this for a fact that it is not a fact. If it is a fact, everyone would agree because there are no counter-arguments. If there are solid evidences they should be avail to everyone and I hope we do not need to wait for someone to publish-- I do not understand the need for publishing facts. A hypothesis turns to be a fact once it is peer reviewed and agreed by experts. It will be published if so. I have a hard time understand this btw. Hope you will publish those solid evidences that will help everyone out and there won't be any rebuts. Best, JoeJoshhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/08191352209514641958noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3442555339667770589.post-44506672941650790792018-04-24T14:00:54.560+05:302018-04-24T14:00:54.560+05:30Hi Joe,
Your comment is superfluous. Be specific...Hi Joe, <br /><br />Your comment is superfluous. Be specific where you differ and tell why you differ / or don't agree. <br /><br />There is a proto language to both Tamil and Sanskrit as both have been refined and developed simultaneously according to Tamil texts. This article gives conjectural evidence to what that could be. There are solid evidences to show that Pali fits with the bill. They are yet to be written in this series. Jayasree Saranathan https://www.blogger.com/profile/01048252011566427834noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3442555339667770589.post-43229491954106462842018-04-24T11:05:15.854+05:302018-04-24T11:05:15.854+05:30Hi Jay,
I read your post but there is no solid ev...Hi Jay,<br /><br />I read your post but there is no solid evidence and no coherent texts therefore. The writer used suggestions from various studies and purely based on assumptions and similarities. Hypotheses can not be valid unless it is proven. I found this is informative but it surely oversees evidence based practice. This kind of studies would mislead people and just favour their opinion; as a result, they will be happy to carry on with their fallacious beliefs. See most people consider this as true and would even treat it is factual. This is the bad consequence of this kind of article. In other words this is a holy grail for many propagandists. I saw no evidence for Pali is the precursor of Tamil and Sanskrit here ( you suggested me to read on). Unfortunately this article also does not water and it is a far cry from scientific studies or academia. It does not convince any enthusiastic academic persona as it is not on par with academic or scientific expository.However, there are some hints but it would still remain as secondary evidences, not primary. Regards,JoeJoshhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/08191352209514641958noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3442555339667770589.post-71372141343534626292018-01-17T01:09:53.148+05:302018-01-17T01:09:53.148+05:30There many many Madurai- both vada & then in m...There many many Madurai- both vada & then in many places. All these are in memory of original vada & then Madurai. Specific feature of vada Madurai is river Yamuna- thozhunai in Tamil. Is it there in the vada Madurai of Dindugal? <br /> Jayasree Saranathan https://www.blogger.com/profile/01048252011566427834noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3442555339667770589.post-19519113001220532982018-01-16T23:49:27.365+05:302018-01-16T23:49:27.365+05:30Mam,
I would like to bring to your notice that the...Mam,<br />I would like to bring to your notice that there is place called Vadamadurai (vada-Madurai) in Dindugal district. This is being brought to attention to inform that Tenmadurai has a Vadamadurai very close by in Dindugal. The wikipedia reference is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VadamaduraiDJhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/01563408324972374271noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3442555339667770589.post-49777163176026736892017-06-22T11:38:29.735+05:302017-06-22T11:38:29.735+05:30I think you are research oriented person because i...I think you are research oriented person because its seen in your post.Thanks for it. keep posting.<br /><br /><a href="www.animaastrologer.com" rel="nofollow"> Best Astrologer in Delhi </a><br /> <a href="www.animaastrologer.com" rel="nofollow"> Astrologer in Delhi </a> <br />sureshhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/14726193558282475158noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3442555339667770589.post-68175810501802682252017-06-10T21:18:06.995+05:302017-06-10T21:18:06.995+05:30It comes in Porul adhikaram 74. It is in Purath th...It comes in Porul adhikaram 74. It is in Purath thinai iyal. Check out this link. Click Ilakkanam in the list and click Tholkappiyam. Then click porul adhikaram. It gives it combined as porul adhikaram, purath thinai iyal verse no 74. http://www.tamilvu.org/library/libindex.htmJayasree Saranathan https://www.blogger.com/profile/01048252011566427834noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3442555339667770589.post-46833036693164385172017-06-10T20:36:57.036+05:302017-06-10T20:36:57.036+05:30Good Research..Jayasree
One quick check ...Does t...Good Research..Jayasree<br /><br />One quick check ...Does the 7 Varnas in Tholkappium come under Chapter 3 - Poruladhigaram - 2. Purathinayiyal 16 rather than 74 as quoted here?<br /><br />Source: http://www.projectmadurai.org/pm_etexts/utf8/pmuni0100.htmlV.M.GURUPRASATHhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/18413519571943503876noreply@blogger.com